Religion and State among the Palestinian-Arabs in Israel: A Multicultural Entrapment

Israeli Jolly Ball

Religion and State among the Palestinian-Arabs in Israel: A Multicultural Entrapment

Tuesday, 9 November 2021 - 2:15pm to 4:00pm
The MEC Board Room, The Kirdar Building, St. Antony's College
Michael Karayanni (Hebrew University)
Yaacov Yadgar (OSGA and DPIR)
Israel Studies Seminar


The religion-and-state debate in Israel is Jewish centred and systematically disregards the Palestinian-Arab minority. This is rather puzzling. For the religion-and-state debate in many other countries does take up conflicts pertaining to minority religions, and the Palestinian-Arab minority did generate quite a diverse series of questions that could have easily qualified as part of the existing debate. In this article, I decode this anomaly by pointing out the existence of a legal matrix in the Israeli religion-and-state debate. This matrix identifies the recognition accorded to Jewish religious institutions and norms as "public and coercive" but that accorded to the Palestinian-Arabs as "private and liberal". In the second part of this article, I point out some of the legal implications of this matrix as well as critically evaluate if what seems to be "private and liberal" is in fact as such. 

Michael Karayanni was born in Kafr-Yasif, a Palestinian village located in the Western Galilee in Israel. After obtaining his undergraduate law degree at Bar-Ilan University (LLB 1990) and being admitted to the Israeli bar, he went on to pursue graduate studies in law in the United States (George Washington University, LLM 1994, University of Pennsylvania, SJD 2003) and in Israel (Hebrew University of Jerusalem, LLD 2000). His academic base is at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, where he is today the Bruce W. Wayne Professor of International Law. Throughout his career at Hebrew University he has held a number of administrative positions, among them Dean of the Faculty of Law, Academic Director of Minerva Center for Human Rights, Director of Sacher Institute for Legislative Research and Comparative Law and Founding Director of Center of the Study of Multiculturalism and Diversity. He has also held visiting positions at Wissenschaftskolleg zu Berlin, Georgetown Law Center, Melbourne Law School, Stanford Law School, Yale Law School and Institute for Advanced Study in Princeton. Recently he was elected to the Institut de Droit International. His work focuses on issues of private international law and interreligious law, civil procedure and multiculturalism.  

Places are limited to 10 people only. First come, first served basis. The first 10 people to arrive at the seminar on the day will get a place; once capacity is reached we will not be able to accept any more audience members. Those who attend must check-in using the NHS QR code provided by the college (or may alternatively give their name and contact details on the door).

COVID-19 Safety Information

If you have symptoms of COVID-19 or have been in contact with someone with COVID-19, please do not attend this event. We encourage attendees to wear a face covering at all indoor OSGA events unless exempt. We encourage attendees to respect social spacing, by leaving the seat next to them free, where possible and to use handwashing and hand sanitisation facilities regularly. We request that attendees, particularly those who are not double vaccinated, perform LFD tests before attending OSGA events. All attendees at OSGA events are expected to have pre-registered through Eventbrite.

All attendees at St Antony's College events must:

  • Take a lateral flow test on the morning of the event. If positive, stay at home
  • Stay home if you feel unwell
  • Wear a face covering where indicated
  • Be considerate of other people’s space
  • Wash your hands regularly with soap or sanitiser.

The latest University guidance on the use of face coverings should be checked and followed: unless exempt, you are asked wear one while moving around indoor spaces, where possible, while seated, particularly during larger events.

Attendees are asked to use the official NHS QR code posters displayed throughout the College site.

College general COVID guidance can be found here.

Attendees need to have one of:

  1. Proof of COVID-19 vaccination status,
  2. Registration (via NHS app) of a negative Lateral Flow Device test (LFD test) taken in the last 48 hours, or
  3. Proof of natural immunity via a positive PCR test taken within 180 days of the event, but following the 10-day isolation period