The art of triangulation: Will Greece's debt crisis finally come to an end?
Charles Enoch and Kalypso Nicolaidis
Restoring trust in finance: From principal-agent to principled agent
Donal Hay, Gordon Menzies, Thomas Simpson, David Vines
We outline a narrative of how attempts to solve the principal-agent problem for financial managers have eroded moral restraint, leading to fewer principled agents. Bonus-based compensation inspired by Jensen and Meckling (1976) appears to have contributed to unfavourable attitudes, through motivational crowding out (Simpson, 2016). We classify the moral restraint of earlier times as either ‘moral optimization’—standard utility theory appended with other-regarding preferences (Becker, 1981)—or as ‘moral prioritization’—a commitment to not doing wrong (Sen, 1976). Disciplining unethical managers in a post deregulation world by competition policy runs into serious practical difficulties, rendering it necessary to address their moral motivations. In contrast, trustworthiness sustains trust.
Different lessons for Europe from American financial history - a counterpoint to Mr Gaspar
G. Russell Kincaid
Journal of European Integration
Sovereign debt restructuring played a key role in placing the US federal government on a sound financial footing under its new Constitution in 1789. State governments in the US, like national governments in the euro area, do not have bankruptcy protection. US state governments have not defaulted since the Great Depression, owing to a credible no-bailout policy by the federal government coupled with fiscal rules and an effective signalling of default risk by private markets. At the municipal level in the US, bankruptcy protections apply and recent default experience is very low. With permanent sovereign bailout mechanisms in place in the euro area, sovereign bankruptcy provisions might lessen officially induced moral hazard, allowing market discipline to function more effectively with respect to euro area countries than previously.
G. Russell Kincaid served as a discussant of Vitor Gaspar’s paper, which was delivered at a seminar, The Governance of EMU: Recasting Political, Fiscal, and Financial Integration, on 11–12 March 2014 sponsored by PEFM.
Integration or disintegration? Europe at the crossroads in 2016: The view from Germany, Greece, Poland and the UK
This conference was hosted at St Antony's College, University OF Oxford, in partnership with the Oxford Martin School, which hosted the preceding companion conference on The Future of Europe: The Drivers of Change on April 27, 2016. The two-day conference was, inter alia, part of a series of events in celebration of the fortieth anniversary of the founding of the European Studies Centre at St. Antony's College.
Governance of the European Monetary Union: Recasting Political, Fiscal and Financial Integration
Edited by Erik Jones, Francisco Torres
The crisis in the euro area is a defining moment in the history of European integration. It has revealed major flaws in the architecture of the European Union; it has challenged European institutions to shape an appropriate response; and it has tested the patience of a European public that is eager to see their economic prospects improve again. This volume brings together some of the world’s top economists and policymakers to explain how this crisis came about and what is to be done. The policy agenda these chapters establish is going to be difficult to implement, not least because of popular misunderstanding and political opposition. This book argues, that it is essential that European policymakers push forward this agenda or they run the risk of seeing Europe’s economies fall back into crisis. This book was previously published as a special issue of the Journal of European Integration.
The book is dedicated to Max Watson.
Avoiding another crisis in the Euro area: Public and private imbalances and national policy responses
Russell Kincaid and Max Watson
Journal of European Integration
1 Sep. 2015
The PEFM Discussion Draft entitled Avoiding New Crises in the Euro Area: Private Imbalances, Capital Flows, and National Responses posted in December 2013 (see below) was published in the Journal of European Integration in September 2015. After receiving comments during various seminars including notably at the European Commission and the European Stability Mechanism, and incorporating comments from referees, this Discussion Draft was accepted with revisions including to the title. This published paper notes that early critics of the euro’s design pointed to the disruptive potential — both political and economic — of country-specific shocks in a monetary union that is a far cry from an optimal currency area. The euro crisis has confirmed the risks associated with a ‘one-size-fits-all’ monetary policy, decentralized financial supervision, and inadequate fiscal backstops. This article examines how the active use of national fiscal policies and macroprudential policies can mitigate these risks. Cross-border coordination of macroprudential policies is essential to ensure their effectiveness. In addition, area-wide reforms are necessary including a more complete banking union with a well-funded common backstop.
Capital Failure: Rebuilding Trust in Financial Services
Edited by Nicholas Morris and David Vines
21 May, 2015
- Considers the lack of trust that emerged following deregulation of the financial sector
- Clear exposition of the meaning of trust in finance
- Historical summary of how the financial crisis involved the breakdown of trust
- Chapters refer to each other and are inspired by interdisciplinary research built around a unique inter-disciplinary and multi-disciplinary seminar
- Contributions from a wide range of highly reputed authors across a range of disciplines
- Offers practical suggestions for policy improvement
Policy coordination - Assigning roles to macroeconomic and macroprudential policies
On Thursday 10 July, Russell Kincaid participated in an IMF-Chatham House seminar on international policy coordination in Washington DC. He presented a paper, co-authored with Max Watson, a revised version of which can be accessed here.
<!-- Added condition for Music for Marval call 583828 -->
How are emerging and developing countries affected by monetary and regulatory spillovers from advanced economies?
On 12 February, an international roundtable on Monetary and Regulatory Spillovers was hosted by the Global Economic Governance Programme and the Blavatnik School of Government, in association with PEFM. The workshop report presents key conclusions as well as contributions by a number of participants.
Macroprudential policies in the Euro Area: Issues for the next ten years
This paper explores the potential role and contribution of macroprudential policies in the euro area. It places these policies in a historical context, recognising that there was much relevant experience during previous decades, both in Europe elsewhere. In the euro area setting, the authors see these policies as potentially playing an important role, given the absence of national monetary policies, the prevalence of highly bank-centric financial systems, the limited flexibility of individual economies, and the potential costs of financial instability - including through contagion channels. The institutional framework for initiating and coordinating policies influencing financial stability is also discussed. The paper warns, however, about inherent limitations in the effectiveness of macroprudential measures, whether structural or (particularly) cyclical in design. Achieving 'macroprudence' will typically require the coordination of macroprudential actions with other policies - such as very strong microprudential and resolution regimes, and a well-judged fiscal policy at the national level. It will also be dependent on the degree of flexibility in the real economy, as well as macroprudential coordination across countries to contain leakages and spillover effects.
International policy coordination: Macroprudential policies and the "new normal"
In this PEFM discussion draft, Russell Kincaid and Max Watson analyze the potential role of macroprudential policy, including capital flow measures, in containing problematic spillovers from low interest rates in key currency economies to economies in the rest of the world, as well as the market volatility that may arise from prospective exiting from low interest rates. The authors explore the conduct of monetary and macroprudential policies in a variety of country circumstances and examine the nature, uses, and limitations of macroprudential tools. Special attention is given to the implications of nonbank financial activities for the conduct of macroprudential policies. Issues related to domestic and international coordination of macroprudential policies are scrutinized. While macroprudential policies can be surgically targeted at sectoral booms, the authors note that fiscal, monetary and exchange rate policies remain the “big bazookas”.
Avoiding new crises in the Euro Area: Public and private imbalances, capital flows and national policy responses
In this PEFM Discussion Draft, Russell Kincaid and Max Watson review the role of national fiscal and macroprudential policies in safeguarding financial stability under EMU. Experience during the euro area crisis confirmed some earlier concerns that country-specific booms and downturns under the common monetary policy could result in problematic swings in competitiveness and protracted current account imbalances. Moreover, developments in capital flows, credit growth, risk premia and asset prices tended to exacerbate these tensions and led to serious instability. In light of this experience, a more active use of national fiscal and macroprudential policies is called for in order to dampen such country-specific economic and financial cycles, thus complementing planned measures to strengthen the institutional architecture of EMU.
The implications of macroprudential policies for International policy coordination
In this PEFM Discussion Draft, prepared for a Chatham House-IMF seminar, Russell Kincaid and Max Watson explore the role of macroprudential policy in relation to other policy frameworks. They suggest that this role differs in importance under floating and fixed exchange regimes. The potential gains from co-ordination in this area promise to be greater than from the co-ordination of macroeconomic policies. The context of monetary union offers important opportunities for co-ordination, but there may be some tension between the goal of dampening cross-border capital flows for macroprudential reasons and the objective of fostering a single financial market.
Bring credit back into the monetary policy framework!
In this PEFM Policy Brief, Michael Biggs and Thomas Mayer argue that developments in credit matter crucially for financial stability and for the sustainability of growth. They underscore that changes in the flow of credit (rather than in the stock of credit) contain valuable information concerning cyclical developments in the economy. In their view monetary policy needs to internalise these insights if future crises are to be avoided.
Regulatory capture to regulatory space?
On 1 March, the Foundation for Law, Justice and Society hosted a workshop at Wolfson College on New Issues in Regulation, in the course of which Max Watson's paper: 'Regulatory Capture Revisited' was discussed. The paper is the first product of the PEFM workstream on Policy Capture.
Financial integration in the Euro Area - Lessons from Ireland?
Lecture delivered by Max Watson on November 2nd, 2012 in Galway, Ireland.
The political economic sources of the financial crisis
Discussion draft, prepared by an informal working group under the programme.